1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.
  2. Some new members aren't following the advice on posting links - please read it!
  3. If you're looking for the LostCousins site please click the logo in the top left corner - these forums are for existing LostCousins members only.
  4. Only registered members can see all the forums - if you've received an invitation to join please register NOW!

Interesting Guardian article

Discussion in 'Jewish ancestors' started by mowsehowse, Jun 13, 2019.

  1. mowsehowse

    mowsehowse LostCousins Member

  2. jorghes

    jorghes LostCousins Member

    Interesting. I doubt my Ashkenazi Jewish heritage (at such a small percentage) would be enough, although I must have inherited that DNA marker for it to appear at all. I wonder if there is a percentage on your Jewishness?
    Technically my grandmother would be considered Jewish, as it was passed from her grandmother (her closest Jewish relative) and through her mother; even though her grandmother married outside of the faith (and was the only one of her family to do so.) and her daughter married a Baptist minister...
  3. mowsehowse

    mowsehowse LostCousins Member

    Technically your grandma would be allowed to marry a Jewish man.....
    But that's the thing isn't it?
    Is "Jewish" in the blood, or is it just a religion?
    My husband is a scientist and he is arguing there is no way it can be in the DNA.
    My father was born Jewish, my mother was not. All Gentiles regard me as Jewish, but according to Jewish faith I am not.
  4. Bryman

    Bryman LostCousins Megastar

    That was my first question when I read the article.
    As a result of my research, I have discovered that a few generations back within my mother's ancestors, one line were Jews, tracing back to a Chief Rabbi about 1600. My mother was not a Jew and I don't believe that her mother was. However, would I be considered Jewish if my DNA contained the appropriate marker?
  5. mowsehowse

    mowsehowse LostCousins Member

    Hoping we have a Rabbi who reads this forum, because I can't answer the question.
  6. jorghes

    jorghes LostCousins Member

    The technicalities (the last I talked to someone who was actually Jewish) mean that "Jewishness" passes down the matrilineal line - but I think there would have to be belief, community acceptance and the rest in order to remain in the community.

    I doubt my 3x great grandmother was considered a "proper" Jew once she married a non-Jewish (mainly English) man who attended a Baptist church, and most likely not when they separated... And while her family is buried within the Hebrew section of the cemetery, she's in the Methodist section. (Regardless, she does seem to have been quite close to her family).

    The article did mention something about those who identified as Jewish - and the idea of DNA testing perhaps interfering with this identification of Jewishness.

    But it is a very interesting question.
    It's true about the insular community - the largest proportion of the DNA results that I have for my grandmother are from her Jewish relations!
  7. mowsehowse

    mowsehowse LostCousins Member

    I found this list of forbidden marriages in UK according to Canon Law, dating from 1560. < http://www.genetic-genealogy.co.uk/Toc115570145.html >
    In the UK there were quite wide boundaries on what was considered incestuous, i.e. the mixing of DNA.
    But my understanding is that historically, within Jewish communities, one of the greatest priorities for the Match Maker was to be sure the proposed match was sufficiently Jewish, which, particularly in smaller communities, inevitably resulted in the marriage of close cousins.

Share This Page